Peter Oltchick and Scott Greenhut

S&P’s Why Not Us?!

50 years of friendship, one shared obsession. Join two NY natives as they break down the local sports scene and national headlines with the wit and wisdom only a half-century of fandom can provide.

Latest Episode

S&P’s Why Not US?!: Episode #4

May 31, 2026 31:14

NBA Deep Dive; Western Conference Finals Game 7; Preview of Finals with the New York Knicks. French Open Recap to Date; new winner on tap besides Sinner or Alcaraz. Lightning Round: i) Nanoneedle Scope 2.0, ii) NHL Stanley Cup Final, …

Latest Episodes

View all →
Ch. 04
Chapter № 004 31:14

S&P’s Why Not US?!: Episode #4

NBA Deep Dive; Western Conference Finals Game 7; Preview of Finals with the New York Knicks. French Open Recap to Date; new winner on tap besides Sinner or …

Ch. 03
Chapter № 003 42:21

S&P’s Why Not Us?!: Episode #3

NBA Playoffs including the Knicks in the Conference Finals!; MLB - Teams overachieving and underachieving vs. expectations; MLB Game Length; French Open Preview; Lighting Round; PS - Beyond …

Ch. 02
Chapter № 002 36:00

S&P's Why Not Us?!: Episode #2

NFL Draft Recap with a focus on Jets and Giants and thoughts on Pittsburgh as host city. NBA Playoffs Check-in. Lighting Round: Ohtani, NHL Quick Hit, favorite Non-Knick; …

Ch. 01
Chapter № 001 42:10

S&P’s Why Not Us?! Episode #1

NBA Playoff Preview: West, East and Knicks Deep Dive; MLB Check-in including the ABS system and an underrated statistic; Lightning Round; PS: an off the field segment.